Treasure Island is a laid-back barrier island on Florida’s Gulf Coast, where restaurants cluster along Gulf Boulevard and are steps from the sand.
The vibe here is casual and warm. Outdoor decks, cold drinks, and sunset views define the dining scene. Seafood dominates menus, but you’ll find fantastic burgers, pizza, and comfort food throughout the island.
Many spots are family-friendly by day and turn lively at night, especially during peak season from February through May and holiday weekends.
To make the most of your visit, be sure to book your accommodation in advance, and keep reading to discover our favorite dining spots on the island.
1. Middle Grounds Grill
- Hours: Dinner daily
- Address: 10925 Gulf Boulevard
- Food: Upscale seafood and steaks
Middle Grounds Grill is the island’s finest spot for an elevated meal. The menu features expertly prepared grouper, seafood risotto, and daily fresh catch preparations inspired by the Florida Middle Grounds fishing area.
The atmosphere balances upscale dining with a family-friendly feel, perfect for a special dinner without being stuffy. Guests can also enjoy a carefully curated wine list that perfectly complements the variety of seafood and steak dishes.
Middle Grounds Grill delivers culinary perfection in every bite, making it a must-visit on Treasure Island, whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just craving a memorable meal.
2. Caddy’s Treasure Island
- Hours: Open daily, morning to evening
- Address: 9000 West Gulf Boulevard
- Food: Casual seafood, bar bites
Caddy’s is an island institution where you can grab a table right in the sand. Order fish tacos, blackened chicken tenders, or shrimp baskets while enjoying live music most afternoons.
It’s family-friendly during the day and shifts to a lively vibe as the sun sets. Guests often sip on cold drinks and cocktails, making it a perfect spot to kick back after a day at the beach.
Whether you’re stopping by for a casual lunch or an evening with friends, Caddy’s offers a welcoming atmosphere for all ages and occasions.
3. Ricky T’s Bar & Grille
- Hours: Lunch through late night
- Address: 10601 Gulf Boulevard
- Food: Pub fare, seafood baskets
Head to Ricky T’s for an upbeat atmosphere with sports on TV and frequent live bands. The menu covers seafood baskets, grouper sandwiches, and classic pub favorites. It’s a fun spot for groups who want good food with entertainment.
Ricky T’s also hosts game nights and special events, making it a lively destination for parties and gatherings. Whether you’re catching a big game or enjoying live music, this restaurant offers a vibrant, social dining experience that captures the casual spirit of Treasure Island.
4. Sea Dog Brewing Company
- Hours: Lunch and dinner
- Address: 9610 Gulf Boulevard
- Food: Brewpub fare, New England-inspired seafood
This waterfront brewpub pairs house-brewed beer with fish and chips, seafood sandwiches, and comfort food, making it a solid stop when you’re craving craft beverages alongside your meal.
The relaxed atmosphere and friendly staff make Sea Dog Brewing Company a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Its waterfront location offers scenic views, perfect for enjoying a casual lunch or dinner.
Whether you’re a beer enthusiast or just looking for a laid-back dining experience with fresh New England-inspired seafood, this spot delivers quality and flavor in every bite.
5. Sloppy Joe’s on the Beach
- Hours: All day, breakfast through dinner
- Address: Bilmar Beach Resort, 10650 Gulf Boulevard
- Food: Classic beach bar fare
Sloppy Joe’s is a big two-tiered deck with around 150 seats and offers panoramic sunset views over the Gulf. The menu features burgers, fish sandwiches, wings, and tropical cocktails served in a beach-chic setting.
Whether you’re stopping by for a refreshing drink or a full meal, Sloppy Joe’s provides a quintessential Gulf Coast experience that keeps guests coming back season after season.
If you’re heading down for the evening, arrive early to beat the sunset crowd and savor the view. This iconic spot is perfect for casual dining with friends or family, offering a lively atmosphere that captures the essence of Treasure Island’s beach culture.
6. BRGR Kitchen + Bar
- Hours: All-day breakfast, lunch, and dinner
- Address: Treasure Island Beach Resort, 10800 Gulf Boulevard
- Food: Gourmet burgers, craft cocktails
The island’s specialty burger spot delivers creative burger builds, hand-cut fries, and cocktails made with house-made syrups and fresh-pressed juices.
Direct Gulf views make this place ideal for a casual lunch or sunset drink. The menu also features seasonal specials that highlight local ingredients, ensuring a fresh and flavorful experience every time.
With its laid-back atmosphere and attentive service, BRGR Kitchen + Bar is a favorite among both locals and visitors looking for a relaxed yet satisfying meal by the water.
7. Ka’Tiki
- Hours: Early morning to very late night
- Address: 8803 West Gulf Boulevard
- Food: Simple bar food, snacks
This tiki-hut-style beach bar keeps it simple with burgers, sandwiches, and snacks. Live music and long hours make it a go-to spot for a relaxed drink any time, day or night.
Its laid-back vibe and friendly staff create a welcoming atmosphere, perfect for unwinding after a day on the beach. If you’re in the mood to grab a quick bite or enjoy a casual evening with friends, Ka’Tiki offers a true taste of Treasure Island’s casual beach culture.
8. Gigi’s Italian Restaurant
- Hours: Dinner nightly
- Address: 105 Treasure Island Causeway
- Food: Traditional Italian-American
A family-owned gem dating back to the 1960s, Gigi’s serves from-scratch pasta, classic red-sauce dishes, and delicious pizzas. Whether you’re enjoying a romantic dinner or a casual meal with family, Gigi’s remains a beloved Treasure Island staple.
The cozy, candle-lit dining room feels like old-school Florida, perfect for those craving a break from seafood. With its warm, inviting atmosphere and attentive service, Gigi’s offers a nostalgic dining experience that feels both authentic and comforting.
The menu features traditional Italian-American favorites made with fresh ingredients, ensuring each dish bursts with flavor.
9. Britt’s Pizza
- Hours: Lunch and dinner
- Address: 10709 Gulf Boulevard
- Food: Coal-fired pizza, Italian comfort food
Stop at Britt’s for coal-fired or stone-oven pies, calzones, and late-night slices. Outdoor seating under string lights creates a casual atmosphere that’s hard to beat after a beach day.
Known for its friendly service and consistently delicious offerings, Britt’s is a favorite among both locals and visitors. The relaxed vibe and convenient location make it an ideal spot to unwind with a slice and a cold drink after a day in the sun.
10. Foxy’s Cafe
- Hours: Breakfast, lunch, and dinner
- Address: 160 107th Avenue
- Food: Classic diner fare
This diner delivers pancakes, omelets, home fries, and bottomless coffee in a casual Old Florida setting. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere create a welcoming environment, ideal for families and solo travelers alike.
An array of hearty breakfast options makes it the perfect morning stop before you hit the sand. Enjoy classic lunch and dinner favorites alongside daily specials that showcase fresh, local ingredients.
It’s a great place to fuel up with a satisfying meal that captures the charm of Treasure Island’s dining scene.
FAQ
What’s the best time to visit Treasure Island restaurants?
February through May is peak season with the biggest crowds. For shorter waits, try early-bird dinners or weekday visits. Sunset hour is popular at beachfront spots, so arrive 30–45 minutes early for prime outdoor seating.
Do Treasure Island restaurants accept walk-ins?
Most casual beach bars like Caddy’s and Sloppy Joe’s are first-come, first-served. Upscale spots like Middle Grounds Grill recommend reservations, especially for weekend dinners and groups of six or more.
Are there kid-friendly options on Treasure Island?
Yes, most restaurants welcome families, especially earlier in the evening. Sloppy Joe’s, Foxy’s Cafe, and Gigi’s Italian offer relaxed atmospheres for kids. Some spots, like Ka’Tiki, get louder with live music later at night.
Planning Your Treasure Island Food Adventure
There’s so much to do in Treasure Island, and checking out the dining scene plays an important part in any itinerary.
Treasure Island’s relaxed dress codes and casual dining scene make it easy to unwind and savor the island’s flavors. Whether you’re planning a special dinner or grabbing a laid-back bite by the beach, the key is to soak in the easygoing vibe and enjoy every taste.
Ready to experience Treasure Island’s vibrant restaurant scene for yourself? Book your stay today and find the perfect accommodation to complement your culinary adventure.
